Prancing in the Darkness for Hall of Fame?

[Sammy]

PRANCING IN THE DARKNESS
Out of the Darkness x Dancing in the Moonlight

Race Record: 27 16-10-5
Consistency: 87%

RACES WON:
DSRC Racemeet #5
1st Place
SLS Racemeet 3
1st Place
[ GAFi National Colt Stakes ]
1st Place
DSRC Racemeet #3
1st Place
SM2 Racemeet #1
1st Place
[ Annual Firebrand Gold Cup ]
1st Place
[ Firebrand End Of Year Special ]
1st Place
Firebrand 1 Day Entry
1st Place
SAI's Hidden Treasure Race
1st Place
Firebrand Showjupming
1st Place
One on one race against Toda la perfección
1st Place
One on one race against Another Bad Dream
1st Place
One on one race against Flash Of Lightning
1st Place
One on one race against Wild Flower
1st Place
One on one race against Shiver Me Timbers
1st Place
One on one race against True Enough
1st Place

----------------------------------------------

Prancer comes from old lines on an old track but with that he faced other monster turf favorites in his time. While he did not race on GHF I think this stallion has earned the title especially if he faced those of Hall of Fame True Enough, Hall of Fame Wild Flower, Shiver Me Timbers and beat them fairly. He favors the turf surface and became well known to everyone. His consistency stayed strong and played a nasty game against his opponents. I think this head strong stallion deserves this title with his record and consistency. What do you think?


(Thought I would give him a shot at the title)

[Cruisey]

I think he is a great horse Sammy, but I don't think show jumping can count towards his HOF title. I'm not sure how well known his won races are either, as I've never heard of them before. He did face some tough horses like Shiver Me Timbers and True Enough, but I personally don't understand his racing record and what those races are from.

[S u N f r O s t ~]

This horse raced practically during the Dark Ages xD

To clarify his record, the majority of these races are from foreign tracks and the match races were all randomized against one horse. There is also a show jumping result that snuck in there.

I voted no. He doesn't have the record, the wins on GHF, the accomplishments for HoF in my opinion. I do appreciate the time period he came from, but with even that in consideration his races and wins were not on GHF and that voids him out of this HoF pretty strongly for me.

[Deleted]

I am very much with Frosty on my reasoning for saying no here - a lot of his career was on foreign tracks and I don't feel he ever excelled at GHF all that much.

[S u N f r O s t ~]

There have been 5 votes so far. Would like to see at least 7 before considering closing.

[Sammy]

This can close!